If you’re an aspiring teacher trying to decide between teaching middle school or high school, this is understandably a difficult decision. Both grade levels come with their own unique challenges and rewards that need to be carefully weighed.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: Teaching middle school allows you to have more fun and influence on students’ development, but requires extreme patience and stamina. High school teaching enables you to go more in-depth into your subject area, but students can be more apathetic and difficult to engage.

In this comprehensive guide, we will dive deep into the key differences between teaching these two grade levels in terms of the student mentality, classroom management, subjects and curriculum, extracurricular activities, long term rewards, and more.

We will also offer tips from experienced teachers to help you determine which level is the best fit for your skills, interests, and teaching goals.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Tia (@lifewithmiss.t)


The Student Mentality

Middle School Students

When it comes to the student mentality, middle school students are often characterized by their curiosity and eagerness to explore new ideas. They are at a stage in their lives where they are transitioning from childhood to adolescence, and this is reflected in their behavior and attitudes towards learning.

Middle school students are typically more open to trying new things and taking risks in their education.

They are also known for their energy and enthusiasm, which can be both a blessing and a challenge for teachers. Middle school students have a natural curiosity about the world around them and are eager to ask questions and engage in discussions.

This can create a dynamic and interactive classroom environment where students are actively participating in their own learning.

However, middle school students can also be easily distracted and may struggle with self-discipline. They are still developing their organizational and time management skills, which can make it challenging for them to stay focused on their studies.

As a result, teachers often need to provide structure and guidance to help middle school students stay on track.

High School Students

High school students, on the other hand, have typically developed a more mature and focused approach to their education. They have a better understanding of their goals and aspirations, and are motivated to achieve success in their academic pursuits.

High school students are often more self-disciplined and independent, taking responsibility for their own learning.

They have also developed a greater sense of autonomy and are more capable of managing their time and prioritizing their responsibilities. High school students have a better grasp of long-term planning and are able to balance their academic workload with extracurricular activities and personal commitments.

High school students are also more accustomed to the demands of a rigorous curriculum and are better equipped to handle the challenges that come with it. They have developed critical thinking and problem-solving skills, allowing them to engage in complex discussions and analyze information in a more sophisticated manner.

While high school students may have a more serious and focused approach to their education, it is important to note that they still benefit from a supportive and engaging learning environment. Teachers play a crucial role in fostering a positive and stimulating classroom atmosphere that encourages high school students to continue their intellectual growth.

Understanding the student mentality is essential in determining which grade level is right for you as a teacher. Consider the unique characteristics of middle school and high school students, and think about which age group you feel most comfortable working with.

Ultimately, both grade levels offer their own rewards and challenges, so it is important to choose the one that aligns with your teaching style and passion for education.

Classroom Management

Middle School Classroom Management

Managing a middle school classroom can be challenging yet rewarding. Middle school students are typically between the ages of 11 and 14, and they are going through a period of significant physical and emotional changes.

As a result, they may display more impulsive behavior and have difficulty focusing for long periods of time. To effectively manage a middle school classroom, teachers need to establish clear expectations and rules from the beginning.

They should also use a variety of teaching strategies to keep students engaged and actively involved in the learning process.

One effective strategy for middle school classroom management is to create a positive and supportive classroom environment. This can be achieved by fostering strong relationships with students, showing genuine interest in their lives, and providing opportunities for collaboration and teamwork.

Additionally, implementing a reward system can help motivate students to follow the rules and stay on task. For example, teachers can give out small rewards or privileges to students who consistently demonstrate positive behavior and meet academic goals.

Another important aspect of managing a middle school classroom is addressing discipline issues. It is important for teachers to have a clear and fair discipline policy in place, and to consistently enforce it.

This may involve using consequences such as loss of privileges, time-outs, or parent-teacher conferences. However, it is also important to approach discipline with empathy and understanding, as middle school students are still developing their social and emotional skills.

By providing guidance and support, teachers can help students learn from their mistakes and make positive changes.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Megan DuVarney Forbes (@toocoolformiddleschool)


High School Classroom Management

Classroom management in high school can present its own unique set of challenges. High school students are typically between the ages of 14 and 18, and they are preparing for college or entering the workforce.

They have more independence and are often more focused on their individual goals and interests. To effectively manage a high school classroom, teachers need to establish a balance between providing structure and allowing students the freedom to take responsibility for their own learning.

One important aspect of high school classroom management is creating a positive and respectful classroom culture. This can be achieved by treating students as young adults and involving them in decision-making processes.

Teachers can encourage open discussions and provide opportunities for students to express their opinions and ideas. By fostering a sense of ownership and autonomy, students are more likely to be engaged and invested in their own learning.

In addition to creating a positive classroom culture, high school teachers should also focus on creating a rigorous and challenging academic environment. This can be done by setting high expectations for student achievement and providing opportunities for critical thinking and problem-solving.

Teachers can incorporate real-world examples and hands-on activities to make the material more relevant and engaging for students.

When it comes to discipline in high school, teachers should aim to create a sense of personal responsibility. Instead of relying solely on punitive measures, teachers can help students understand the consequences of their actions and encourage them to take ownership of their behavior.

By promoting self-discipline and accountability, students are more likely to make responsible choices and contribute positively to the classroom community.

Subjects and Curriculum

When considering whether to teach middle school or high school, it’s crucial to understand the differences in subjects and curriculum at each grade level. Both middle school and high school have their own unique set of subjects and requirements.

Middle School Subjects

In middle school, students are introduced to a wide range of subjects that lay the foundation for their future academic journey. The core subjects typically include English, math, science, and social studies.

Additionally, students may also have classes in physical education, foreign languages, and fine arts such as music and art.

Middle school is a transitional period, where students start to explore their interests and develop essential skills. Teachers at this level play a crucial role in fostering a love for learning and providing a well-rounded education.

High School Subjects

High school curriculum becomes more specialized, allowing students to dive deeper into subjects of their choice. In addition to the core subjects of English, math, science, and social studies, high school students have the opportunity to select elective courses based on their interests and future career goals.

High schools typically offer a wide range of electives, including advanced math and science courses, foreign languages, computer science, performing arts, and vocational programs. These courses provide students with the opportunity to explore their passions and gain valuable skills for college or the workforce.

It’s important to note that curriculum requirements may vary from state to state and even between schools. Teachers should stay updated on the specific curriculum guidelines set by their school district to ensure they are providing the necessary education to their students.

Extracurricular Activities

Middle School Extracurriculars

Participating in extracurricular activities is a vital part of a student’s development, and middle school offers a variety of options for students to explore their interests and talents outside of the classroom.

Middle schools typically offer a range of clubs and organizations, such as student government, drama club, band, choir, and sports teams. These extracurricular activities provide students with opportunities to develop leadership skills, foster teamwork, and enhance their overall social and emotional well-being.

For example, joining the student government allows middle school students to have a voice in decision-making processes and improve their public speaking and problem-solving abilities. Drama club offers a creative outlet for students to express themselves and build confidence.

Sports teams not only promote physical fitness but also teach valuable lessons about perseverance, discipline, and sportsmanship.

According to Department of Education, students who participated in extracurricular activities had higher grades and better attendance records compared to those who did not get involved in any extracurriculars.

Additionally, these activities can help students explore potential career interests and build a resume for future college applications.

High School Extracurriculars

When it comes to extracurricular activities, high school offers an even broader range of options for students. High schools often have a wider range of clubs and organizations, including academic clubs, honor societies, community service clubs, and specialized interest groups.

Additionally, high school students have the opportunity to participate in varsity sports, debate teams, music ensembles, and theater productions.

Getting involved in extracurricular activities in high school not only allows students to pursue their passions and interests but also helps them develop valuable skills that will benefit them in college and beyond.

These activities provide students with opportunities to develop leadership skills, enhance their critical thinking abilities, and demonstrate their commitment and dedication.

It’s important for high school students to carefully choose extracurricular activities that align with their interests and goals. By participating in activities that they are genuinely passionate about, students are more likely to excel, make meaningful connections, and have a fulfilling high school experience.

Long Term Rewards

Middle School Teacher Rewards

Teaching middle school can be incredibly rewarding for educators. One of the most significant long-term rewards is the opportunity to make a lasting impact on young students’ lives. Middle school is a critical time in a child’s development, and teachers have the chance to shape their students’ academic and personal growth.


Sieh dir diesen Beitrag auf Instagram an


Ein Beitrag geteilt von Tammy • Resources For Teachers (@theowlteacher)


Furthermore, middle school teachers often get to witness the transformation of their students from timid pre-teens to confident young adults. It’s a joy to see students overcome challenges, develop their talents, and succeed academically.

These rewarding moments can bring a sense of fulfillment and pride to middle school teachers.

High School Teacher Rewards

Teaching high school also offers a range of long-term rewards for educators. One of the most significant rewards is the opportunity to watch students grow into independent thinkers and young adults ready to take on the world.

High school teachers often have the chance to guide their students through important life decisions, such as choosing college majors or career paths.

Additionally, high school teachers frequently witness the academic accomplishments of their students. Whether it’s seeing a student excel in a particular subject, win a scholarship, or graduate with honors, these achievements bring a sense of pride and fulfillment to high school teachers.

Furthermore, high school teachers often have the opportunity to build long-lasting relationships with their students. Many educators become mentors and trusted confidants for students, providing guidance and support throughout their high school journey.

These relationships can be incredibly rewarding as teachers witness their students’ personal growth and success.

Tips for Deciding Between Grade Levels

Assess Your Skills and Preferences

When deciding between teaching middle school and high school, it’s important to assess your skills and preferences. Consider the age group you feel most comfortable working with and the subjects you enjoy teaching the most.

Middle school students are typically between the ages of 11 and 14, while high school students are between the ages of 14 and 18. Middle school teachers often need to have a strong understanding of a wide range of subjects, as they generally teach multiple subjects.

On the other hand, high school teachers often specialize in one or two subjects. Reflect on your strengths and passions to determine which grade level aligns best with your skills and interests.

Observe Classrooms

Another valuable tip for deciding between teaching middle school and high school is to observe classrooms in both grade levels. Reach out to local schools and ask if you can visit a few classes to get a feel for the dynamics and teaching styles at each level.

Pay attention to the engagement levels of the students, the classroom management techniques used by the teachers, and the overall atmosphere of the classrooms. This firsthand experience can provide invaluable insights into what it’s like to teach in either a middle school or high school setting.


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Katie Ring (@hellokatiering)


Talk to Other Teachers

Speaking with experienced teachers who have taught both middle school and high school can offer valuable perspective when making your decision. Reach out to teachers in your network or connect with educators through online forums and communities.

Ask them about their experiences teaching at both levels and what they believe are the key differences between the two. Their insights can help you gain a better understanding of the unique challenges and rewards associated with each grade level, and ultimately aid you in making an informed decision.

Remember, there is no one-size-fits-all answer to whether teaching middle school or high school is right for you. It’s a personal decision that should be based on your skills, preferences, and experiences.

Take the time to reflect on what you enjoy most about teaching and what age group you feel most passionate about guiding and mentoring. Ultimately, the most important thing is to find a grade level where you can make a positive impact on your students’ lives and thrive as an educator.


In summary, middle school and high school teaching both come with their own mix of challenges and rewards. Middle school allows for more direct involvement in student development, but requires incredible patience and classroom management skills.

High school enables you to specialize in a subject area, but students tend to be more apathetic. Assess your own skills and preferences, spend time observing different classrooms, and talk to experienced teachers to determine which grade level is the best fit for you.

Similar Posts